The Boys Who Inspired Peter Pan

Every child knows Peter Pan as the boy who never grew up. Almost nobody knows that the real boys behind him did grow up, and for three of the five, growing up ended in horror.

BACKGROUND It starts before any of them were born. When J.M. Barrie was six years old, his older brother David died in an ice-skating accident the day before his fourteenth birthday, knocked onto the ice by another skater. David had been their mother’s favourite, and her grief never fully lifted. She found one strange comfort in it: David would remain a boy forever. He would never grow up. Young James tried to fill the gap, even wearing his dead brother’s clothes and copying his whistle, and biographers have long argued that this is the true root of Neverland.

Years later, in 1897, Barrie was walking in Kensington Gardens when he met two small boys, George and Jack, out with their nurse and baby brother Peter. Their parents, Arthur and Sylvia Llewelyn Davies, would go on to have five sons in total: George, Jack, Peter, Michael, and Nicholas. Barrie became “Uncle Jim,” inventing stories to entertain them, and Peter Pan was born from those games, an amalgam of all five boys, as Barrie himself put it. Then tragedy hit the family directly. Arthur died in 1907 from a cancer that destroyed part of his jaw. Sylvia died in 1910 from lung cancer. Barrie became the boys’ unofficial guardian.

THE HORROR Peter Pan opened on a London stage in December 1904, three years before real death started arriving. George, the eldest, was killed on 15 March 1915, shot through the head by a German sniper in the trenches near Ypres, Belgium. He was 21. He had written to Barrie the day before he died.

Michael, the brother most say truly shaped Peter Pan’s character, drowned on 19 May 1921 in a notoriously dangerous stretch of the Thames near Oxford called Sandford Pool, alongside his close friend Rupert Buxton. Their bodies were recovered the next day, clasped together in the water. The coroner ruled it an accident, but Michael’s own brothers, and Barrie himself, later admitted they believed it was a suicide pact. It has never been proven either way.

Then there was Peter, the baby whose name Barrie borrowed. He hated it. He called Peter Pan “that terrible masterpiece” and spent decades trying to escape being “the real Peter Pan.” In his final years he worked, on and off, on a private project he grimly nicknamed “the Morgue,” a compilation of his family’s old letters and papers. He wrote in it: “What’s in a name. My God, what isn’t.” He never finished it, giving up when he reached the letters about Michael’s death. On the evening of 5 April 1960, Peter had been drinking at a hotel bar in Sloane Square. He crossed the road to the Underground station and stepped in front of an incoming train. He was 63. It wasn’t the name alone. He had emphysema, a lifelong drinking problem, and had just learned that his wife and all three of his sons carried the fatal, incurable Huntington’s disease. The papers still ran with the story they wanted: “The Boy Who Never Grew Up Is Dead.” “Peter Pan’s Death Leap.” The New York Times wrote: “Barrie’s Peter Pan Killed by a London Subway Train.”

Not every brother met this fate. Jack, the second son, served in the Royal Navy, married, had children, and died naturally in 1959 at 65. Nicholas, the youngest, lived the longest of all of them, into 1980, married with a daughter of his own. The horror wasn’t universal. It came for three of the five.

THE MODERN RELIC In 1929, Barrie quietly gave away the entire copyright to Peter Pan, the play and the book, to Great Ormond Street Hospital for sick children. When the original copyright legally expired in 1987, fifty years after his death, the UK parliament stepped in. The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 wrote a permanent exception into British law, guaranteeing the hospital royalties from UK stage performances and publications of Peter Pan forever. A dead man’s fictional boy still helps pay for treating real sick children today.

In Kensington Gardens stands a bronze statue of Peter Pan, commissioned by Barrie himself. He had it installed in secret overnight on 30 April 1912, with no announcement, so that children arriving the next morning would believe fairies had put it there while they slept.

George, Michael, and Peter’s parents, Arthur and Sylvia, are buried together in a churchyard in Hampstead, north London. Peter himself is buried there too, the boy who never grew up, finally at rest.

← Back to the archive