The Coffins That Would Not Stay Still

The mystery of the Chase Vault is one of the strangest and most genuinely unsolved stories in the history of the supernatural — a sealed stone tomb in Barbados where, again and again, the heavy coffins inside were found violently thrown about, with no possible way for anyone or anything to have got in.

To understand it, picture a burial vault in the churchyard of the Christ Church Parish Church, in the coastal parish of Oistins on the island of Barbados, in the early 1800s. This was no shallow grave. It was a substantial crypt, cut partly into the ground and sealed at its entrance by an enormous slab of blue marble, so heavy it took several men to move it into place. Inside were laid the coffins of a wealthy local family — the Chase family, headed by Colonel Thomas Chase, a plantation owner remembered as one of the most cruel and detested men on the entire island. And it was after his coffins joined the vault that the horror began.

The Horror

The first sign came in 1812. When the vault was opened to bury Colonel Thomas Chase himself — in a lead coffin so massive it reportedly took eight men to carry it — the mourners looked inside and recoiled. The coffins already resting there, including those of two of Chase’s own daughters, were no longer in their neat positions. They had been moved. Thrown about the sealed crypt, scattered and disordered, as though something had flung them across the vault in the dark. Everyone assumed vandalism, or perhaps grave robbers — though nothing had been stolen. The coffins were carefully rearranged, laid back in order, and the great marble slab was sealed shut once more.

But it happened again. And again. Over the following years, each time the vault was reopened to admit a new burial, the same appalling scene met the mourners: the heavy lead coffins — some so weighty a single man could not shift them — were found tossed around the chamber. One had been stood completely on its head. Another, it was said, had been hurled against the wall of the vault with such force that it chipped the stone. And yet, every single time, the massive sealing slab was found undisturbed, exactly as it had been left. Each time, the coffins were solemnly put back in place and the vault re-sealed.

The disturbances became so notorious that in 1819 the Governor of Barbados himself, Lord Combermere, came to oversee a burial and to investigate. The coffins were meticulously arranged. The floor of the vault was strewn with fine white sand, so that any footprint — of a man, an animal, anything — would be instantly visible. The marble slab was cemented into place, and the Governor pressed his own personal seal into the wet cement, so that no one could open it without breaking his mark. Then they waited. When the vault was finally reopened in 1820, the Governor’s seal was found completely intact and unbroken. The cement was undisturbed. And the sand on the floor showed no footprints, no marks, no trace of anything at all. But inside, the coffins had been thrown about once more — the heavy caskets flung into chaos, one reportedly resting upside down against the very door they had just unsealed.

The Modern Relic

That was the end of it. The family and the authorities had finally had enough. Whatever was disturbing the dead, they would no longer fight it. The coffins were removed from the Chase Vault entirely and reburied separately, in scattered graves elsewhere in the churchyard, where the dead were at last allowed to rest in peace. And the vault itself was left open, cleared out, and empty.

The relic is that the Chase Vault still stands today, in the graveyard of the Christ Church Parish Church in Barbados — empty, its door open, exactly as it was left over two hundred years ago. It has become one of the island’s most famous and eerie landmarks, and visitors can walk right up to it and stand before the mouth of the tomb where the coffins were said to move. No one has ever solved it. Earthquakes were considered — but no other vault on the island was disturbed. Flooding was suggested — the vault sits low, and rising water could conceivably lift and float heavy coffins and drop them out of place — and this remains the most popular rational theory, though critics note the vault showed no signs of flooding and the lead coffins were extraordinarily heavy. Some pointed to the fact that several of the men involved were Freemasons, and wondered if the whole thing was an elaborate symbolic tale. And many, then and now, simply believed the vault was cursed — perhaps by the cruelty of Thomas Chase himself. The honest truth is that the surviving records are thin and contradictory, and we will likely never know for certain what happened inside that sealed tomb. But the empty vault is still there, its door standing open in the Caribbean sun — a two-hundred-year-old locked-room mystery you can go and stand beside.

← Back to the archive