The Guests Who Murdered Their Hosts At Glencoe

On 1st February 1692, roughly 120 soldiers from the Earl of Argyll’s Regiment of Foot — mostly Campbells — arrived at the small settlement of Glencoe in the Scottish Highlands. They told the MacDonalds they were there on routine military business and needed quarters.

The MacDonalds took them in. Highland hospitality was sacred — a guest who was fed and sheltered was protected by custom older than any law. To refuse shelter was shameful. To harm a guest was unthinkable. To harm a host was worse.

The Campbells stayed for twelve days. They ate MacDonald food. They drank MacDonald whisky. They played cards with MacDonald men. They warmed themselves at MacDonald fires. They slept under MacDonald roofs.

On 13th February, at five o’clock in the morning, they stood up and started killing.

THE HORROR The orders came from Sir John Dalrymple, the Secretary of State for Scotland, and were signed by King William III. They were explicit:

“You are hereby ordered to fall upon the rebels, the MacDonalds of Glencoe, and to put all to the sword under seventy.”

All to the sword under seventy. Every man, woman and child under the age of seventy was to be killed.

The pretext was administrative. Highland clan chiefs had been ordered to swear an oath of allegiance to William by 1st January 1692. Alasdair Maclain, chief of the Glencoe MacDonalds, was late — he had gone to the wrong place first and only reached Inveraray on 6th January, six days past the deadline.

His oath was accepted by the local sheriff. On paper, it should have been enough. But Dalrymple wanted an example — a demonstration of what happened to any clan that hesitated. The late oath gave him the excuse. The Campbells gave him the weapon.

Captain Robert Campbell of Glenlyon — who had been enjoying MacDonald hospitality for nearly two weeks — received his written orders on the evening of 12th February. They instructed him to “put all to the sword under seventy” and added that “this is by the King’s special command, for the good and safety of the country, that these miscreants be cut off root and branch.”

At five o’clock the next morning, in darkness, in a snowstorm, the killing began.

Alasdair Maclain was shot dead while getting out of bed. His wife was stripped of her clothing. Her rings were torn from her fingers with such force that the soldiers bit them off, tearing the flesh from her hands with their teeth. She died of her injuries the next day.

Thirty‑eight MacDonalds were killed in the settlement — shot, bayoneted or clubbed in their beds, in their doorways, in the snow outside their homes. But the massacre was botched. Some soldiers, disgusted by the orders or unwilling to murder people who had been their hosts, quietly warned families before dawn. Dozens of MacDonalds ran for the hills.

They fled in their nightclothes into a February blizzard in the Scottish Highlands. Temperatures were well below freezing. The passes out of Glencoe were blocked by other troops positioned to intercept escapees. An unknown number — perhaps as many as forty — died of exposure in the mountains: women, children, the elderly, found frozen in the snow in the days that followed.

THE MODERN RELIC Glencoe is now one of the most visited valleys in Scotland — a dramatic glacial landscape drawing hikers, climbers and tourists by the hundreds of thousands every year. The National Trust for Scotland manages the area. A visitor centre tells the story. A memorial cross stands near the site of the settlement.

In the village of Glencoe, there is a pub. Above the door, for over a century, a sign read: “No Campbells.” The sign was eventually removed. The sentiment was not.

The massacre was investigated by the Scottish Parliament in 1695. It concluded that the killings were “murder under trust” — a specific Scottish legal term for killing someone who trusts you. Murder under trust was considered worse than ordinary murder because it destroyed the social contract that made Highland life possible. If a guest could kill a host, no door could ever be safely opened again.

George R.R. Martin has confirmed that the Massacre of Glencoe — along with the Black Dinner of 1440 — was one of his two primary inspirations for the Red Wedding. Both involved the violation of guest right. Both involved killing people who had been fed and sheltered. Both proved that in the real world, the most dangerous place to be could be at someone else’s table.

← Back to the archive